20 December 2024, 1:30 AM
Coonamble parents have been left "disappointed" and "devastated" after it was confirmed that the only public transport to school on the shire's Billeroy Road has been cancelled. NSW Legislative Council member Stephen Lawrence confirmed on Thursday 19 December that the Billeroy Bus Service would not run from the start of the 2025 school year due to an "unsustainably low" numbers of students. However, he said the service could return if numbers reach the eight-student threshold to be financially viable. "It's not a new policy. The government's just responded to a change in the patronage levels," the former Dubbo mayor said. "It's just one of these really unfortunate situations. "I really feel for the families, but ultimately these are resources to be made according to policies. "So, I don't really see a way to get a one-off exception made in this case, to be frank."Labor Member of the Legislative Council (MLC) Stephen Lawrence. IMAGE: supplied As at July 1 2024, the average patronage per trip was two students, according to Transport for NSW (TfNSW), and fell to one student as at 12 December. "On many occasions the service carried no children," a TfNSW spokesperson said. In recent years, the number of students using the service has fluctuated between one and nine, although TfNSW did not allow children further down the road from the route to be included in the count. TfNSW said in July that three children were not included for that reason. Children under the age of six who could take the bus to attend pre-school are also not counted. "With the number of kids that are going to be on our road over the coming years, there's enough numbers to retain a bus run there," farmer James Nalder said. Mr Nalder lives about 20 kilometres from Coonamble on Billeroy Road and has three children expected to begin attending school over the next few years. "It's going to make it harder to attract long-term, permanent staff with families to work for us as well if there's not a bus service that comes to the front gate," he said. Since parents were notified in July that they could lose it, community members and the local council have lobbied hard to keep the service. James and Emma Nalder. IMAGE: Meat & Livestock AustraliaMember for Barwon Roy Butler said he has suggested changes to the bus route to pick up extra students. "Part of the problem is a lack of flexibility in bus routes, which I have often talked about in the past," Mr Butler said. "In this case, an existing bus service had previously taken in Billeroy Road as part of its route, but the route was shortened, leaving some students stranded. "In the past I have talked to the minister about small changes in bus routes to accommodate extra students. There are often simple solutions to these problems, but it just requires a bit more flexibility." A TfNSW spokesperson said the agency has "closely monitored" the number of school children on the route before the decision was made. "Transport staff contacted the bus operator in July 2024 to advise that patronage numbers were under review and the service was in danger of being terminated if numbers did not increase over the second half of the year." "The Billeroy to Coonamble service was removed from the bus operator’s contract, effective 20 December 2024. "Transport for NSW acknowledges the inconvenience to eligible families and invites them to apply for the NSW Government School Drive Subsidy to help offset the cost of school travel." Local grandmother Anne Cullen says the School Drive Subsidy "won't cover the cost, much less the inconvenience." "They pay 73 cents per kilometre one-way once a day, where actually you've got to drive those kilometres four times a day," she said. "Not to mention, people have got to get off tractors, or start work an hour or more later and stop mid-afternoon to drive their children to and from school. "It's absolutely devastating. Those families need that bus. "It's a total disregard for remote rural children." Coonamble mayor Dan Keady said student numbers are "cyclical." "The Billeroy bus run has been around for as long as I have," Cr Keady said. "There mightn't be many numbers at the moment, but it only takes for kids to start hitting school age in two or three families, or new families moving in, and all of a sudden there's demand for it again."